Okay so Rachael Ray has this insanely delish and insanely caloric recipe for Puttanesca that I LOVE…but I admit it’s not the healthiest dish and it’s definitely not low in sodium. So once in a while it’s a treat at my household…but I stumbled across this healthier version in Fitness Magazine and I must say it’s an EXCELLENT substitution that makes it easy for me to have one of my favorite dishes more often without any guilt. Hooray! This calls for spaghetti but I prefer using whole wheat penne pasta instead. You make the call, it’s your belly. Oh and don’t let the anchovies freak you out – you seriously cannot even TASTE them and they are the key to this recipe – I mean it: Leave them IN!!!
Spaghetti (or Penne) Puttanesca
Fitness Magazine, 2008
Ease-Factor Rating: 2. This would be a 1 if it weren’t for the parsley – and I just hate chopping the stuff (it’s so uncooperative!). But seriously, this is a breeze and it’s basically fool-proof. That means a lot coming from me…
Ingredient Search: Produce department and pasta aisle, check! You’ll find capers near the olives (usually) and anchovies near the canned oysters and clams. I’ll give you a tip here and try to get anchovies that are soaked in water, not oil. If you can’t find them that way then give ‘em a light rinse – this just helps cut back on the salt (capers and anchovies are naturally WAY salty).
Vitals: I once figured out Rachel Ray’s version and it was something like 800 calories and 38 grams of fat (albeit mostly the good kind…but still – that’s indecently high for one meal). So now you’ll get why I jumped for joy when I found this recipe. Calories per serving (makes 4) = 493; Protein = 11 g; Carbs = 61 g; Fat = 23 g (3 g saturated); Fiber = 4 g. Unsure about the sodium, which is why I suggest rinsing the anchovies first…don’t salt the pasta water, and use sea or kosher salt instead of table salt (you should make this a regular swap, by the way, since you can use less kosher and sea salt to get the same effect as table salt).
Taste: Soooo yummy and totally comforting! If you’re a pasta lover you’ll really dig this one. I noticed Rachael’s was a bit more flavorful but that probably has something to do with the loads of fat and sodium involved. I can happily ditch those stats knowing I’m getting this great-tasting dinner for less damage control.
Ingredients
- 10 ounces whole-wheat spaghetti (or whole-wheat penne, which is what I use)
- 4 tomatoes, peeled, seeded and chopped
- 1 cup pitted black olives
- 3 ounces canned anchovies, chopped
- 3 tablespoon capers, drained
- Handful of flat-leaf parsley, chopped
- 1 tablespoon + 1/4 cup olive oil (I use a little less than 1/4 cup)
- Black pepper
- Freshly grated Parmesan (optional…unless you live with me)
Directions
Prepare pasta according to the way you like it. Drain. Heat 1 tablespoon olive oil in skillet over medium heat. Throw in anchovies and break up with the back of a spoon or wooden spatula until anchovies melt down (seriously, they melt!). Remove from heat. Place spaghetti, tomatoes, olives, anchovies, capers, parsley and remaining olive oil in a bowl. Season with pepper. Toss pasta and serve with Parmesan on top.
Yum!










